| 1 | Jamie McCrimmon | MTGWHO_105 |
| 4+ | Jamuraan Lion | MTGVIS_010 |
| 4+ | Jandor's Saddlebags | MTG5ED_383 |
| 4+ | Jandor's Saddlebags | MTG4ED_330 |
| 1 | Jandor's Saddlebags | MTG3ED_257 |
| 4+ | Jangling Automaton | MTGWTH_151 |
| 2 | Janjeet Sentry | MTGKaladesh_053 |
| 4+ | Jar of Eyeballs | MTGDarkAscension_152 |
| 4+ | Jar of Eyeballs | MTGCommander2013_244 |
| 3 | Jar of Eyeballs FOIL | MTGDarkAscension_152F |
| 4+ | Jarad's Orders | MTGReturntoRavnica_175 |
| 1 | Jarad's Orders (FOIL) | MTGReturntoRavnica_175F |
| 2 | Jared Carthalion | MTGDMC_002 |
| 4+ | Jared Carthalion, True Heir | MTGCMR_281 |
| 2 | Jareth, Leonine Titan | MTGOnslaught_043 |
| 1 | Jareth, Leonine Titan | MTGCommander2017_061 |
| 1 | Jareth, Leonine Titan | MTGCommanderAnthologyV2_030 |
| 4+ | Jarl of the Forsaken | MTGKHM_100 |
| 2 | Jarl of the Forsaken (FOIL) | MTGKHM_100F |
| 4+ | Jasmine Boreal | MTGTimeshifted_093 |
| 4+ | Jasmine Boreal | MTGLEG_233 |
| 2 | Jasmine Boreal Foil | MTGTimeshifted_093F |
| 4+ | Jasmine Seer | MTGUrzaDestiny_010 |
| 1 | Jasmine Seer Foil | MTGUrzaDestiny_010F |
| 1 | Jason Bright, Glowing Prophet (Surge Foil) (#560) (Foil) | MTGPIP_560F |
| 4+ | Jaspera Sentinel | MTGKHM_178 |
| 3 | Jaspera Sentinel | MTGSCD_194 |
| 3 | Jaspera Sentinel (FOIL) | MTGKHM_178F |
| 1 | Jawbone Duelist (Foil) | MTGONE_018F |
| 4+ | Jawbone Skulkin | MTGEventide_170 |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store