| 4+ | Carrion Screecher | MTGGameNight2019_027 |
| 4+ | Carrion Thrash | MTGShardsofAlara_162 |
| 4+ | Carrion Thrash FOIL | MTGShardsofAlara_162F |
| 4+ | Carrion Wall | MTGNemesis_054 |
| 1 | Carrion Wall FOIL | MTG8ED_121F |
| 4+ | Carrion Wurm | MTGTorment_055 |
| 4+ | Carrionette | MTGTMP_111 |
| 4+ | Carry Away | MTGDarksteel_019 |
| 4+ | Carry Away Foil | MTGDarksteel_019F |
| 2 | Cartel Aristocrat | MTGGatecrash_150 |
| 1 | Carth the Lion (Old-Frame) | MTGMH2_418 |
| 4+ | Cartographer | MTGOdyssey_232 |
| 4+ | Cartographer | MTGExodus_107 |
| 1 | Cartographer Foil | MTGOdyssey_232F |
| 4+ | Cartographer's Hawk | MTGCommander2020_024 |
| 2 | Cartographer's Hawk | MTGSCD_010 |
| 4+ | Cartouche of Ambition | MTGAmonkhet_083 |
| 4+ | Cartouche of Knowledge | MTGAmonkhet_045 |
| 2 | Cartouche of Solidarity | MTGAmonkhet_007 |
| 4+ | Cartouche of Strength | MTGAmonkhet_158 |
| 4+ | Cartouche of Zeal | MTGAmonkhet_124 |
| 4+ | Carven Caryatid | MTGRAV_155 |
| 1 | Carven Caryatid | MTGIconicMasters_156 |
| 4+ | Carven Caryatid (Foil) | MTGRAV_155F |
| 4+ | Cascade Seer | MTGZendikarRising_048 |
| 3 | Cascade Seer (Foil) | MTGZendikarRising_048F |
| 1 | Cascading Cataracts | MTGDMC_202 |
| 1 | Case of the Shattered Pact (Foil) | MTGMKM_001F |
| 4+ | Case of the Shifting Visage | MTGMKC_019 |
| 4+ | Cast Down | MTGDominaria_081 |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store