| 4+ | Pitchburn Devils | MTGMagic2014_149 |
| 4+ | Pitchburn Devils | MTGConspiracy_149 |
| 4+ | Pitchburn Devils | MTGCore Set 2021_156 |
| 1 | Pitchburn Devils (Foil) | MTGMagic2014_149F |
| 1 | Pitchburn Devils (FOIL) | MTGCore Set 2021_156F |
| 1 | Pitchburn Devils FOIL | MTGInnistrad_156F |
| 4+ | Pitchstone Wall | MTGTorment_110 |
| 1 | Pitchstone Wall FOIL | MTGTorment_110F |
| 4+ | Pitfall Trap | MTGZendikar_032 |
| 2 | Pitfall Trap Foil | MTGZendikar_032F |
| 4+ | Pith Driller | MTGNewPhyrexia_069 |
| 2 | Pith Driller Foil | MTGNewPhyrexia_069F |
| 4+ | Pithing Needle | MTGSaviors_158 |
| 4+ | Pithing Needle | MTGMagic2010_217 |
| 1 | Pithing Needle | MTGReturntoRavnica_231 |
| 1 | Pithing Needle (Extended Art) | MTGMID_378 |
| 2 | Pithing Needle (FOIL) | MTGReturntoRavnica_231F |
| 2 | Pithing Needle Foil | MTGSaviors_158F |
| 4+ | Pitiless Gorgon | MTGGuilds of Ravnica_218 |
| 1 | Pitiless Gorgon (FOIL) | MTGGuilds of Ravnica_218F |
| 4+ | Pitiless Horde | MTGDragonsofTarkir_112 |
| 4+ | Pitiless Horde (Prerelease FOIL) | MTGDragonsofTarkir_112Pre |
| 3 | Pitiless Pontiff | MTGRavnica Allegiance_194 |
| 1 | Pitiless Pontiff (FOIL) | MTGRavnica Allegiance_194F |
| 4+ | Pitiless Vizier | MTGAmonkhet_103 |
| 3 | Pixie Guide (Showcase) | MTGAFR_309 |
| 2 | Pixie Queen | MTGLEG_196 |
| 4+ | Plagiarize | MTGTorment_044 |
| 4+ | Plagiarize | MTG9ED_089 |
| 1 | Plagiarize FOIL | MTGTorment_044F |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store