| 4+ | Illusionary Wall | MTGICE_078 |
| 4+ | Illusionist's Bracers | MTGGatecrash_231 |
| 1 | Illusionist's Gambit | MTGCommander2013_047 |
| 4+ | Illusions of Grandeur | MTGICE_079 |
| 4+ | Illusory Ambusher | MTGCommander2020_113 |
| 4+ | Illusory Angel | MTGMagic2015_059 |
| 4+ | Illusory Gains | MTGDragonsofTarkir_059 |
| 4+ | Illusory Wrappings | MTGAmonkhet_058 |
| 4+ | Illustrious Historian | MTGSTX_109 |
| 1 | Illustrious Historian (Foil) | MTGSTX_109F |
| 4+ | Ilysian Caryatid | MTGTherosBeyondDeath_174 |
| 3 | Ilysian Caryatid (FOIL) | MTGTherosBeyondDeath_174F |
| 4+ | Imagecrafter | MTGOnslaught_087 |
| 2 | Imagecrafter Foil | MTGOnslaught_087F |
| 4+ | Imaginary Pet | MTGUrzaSaga_081 |
| 4+ | Imaginary Pet | MTG9ED_082 |
| 2 | Imaginary Threats | MTGHour of Devastation_037 |
| 4+ | Imi Statue | MTGChampions_255 |
| 4+ | Immediate Action | MTGConspiracy_005 |
| 4+ | Immersturm Raider | MTGKHM_141 |
| 4+ | Immersturm Skullcairn | MTGKHM_263 |
| 4+ | Immerwolf | MTGDarkAscension_141 |
| 3 | Immerwolf FOIL | MTGDarkAscension_141F |
| 1 | Imminent Doom | MTGHour of Devastation_098 |
| 3 | Immobilizer Eldrazi | MTGOath of the Gatewatch_097 |
| 4+ | Immobilizing Ink | MTGOdyssey_087 |
| 2 | Immobilizing Ink Foil | MTGOdyssey_087F |
| 1 | Immolating Glare | MTGOath of the Gatewatch_020 |
| 1 | Immolating Glare (FOIL) | MTGOath of the Gatewatch_020F |
| 4+ | Immolating Souleater | MTGNewPhyrexia_139 |
|
|
Yottaquest
Cincinnati's Premier Game Store